Jul 25th, 2008| 01:12 pm | Posted by chasc

Diab Jerius follows up on LOESS techniques with a very nice summary update and finds LOCFIT to be very useful, but there are still questions about how it deals with measurement errors and combining observations from different experiments:

Continue reading ‘loess and lowess and locfit, oh my’ »

Tags:

Diab Jerius,

error,

experimental error,

local regression,

locfit,

Loess,

Lowess,

observational error,

Ping Zhao,

question for statisticians Category:

Algorithms,

Cross-Cultural,

Fitting,

Jargon,

Languages,

Stat,

Uncertainty |

2 Comments
Jun 3rd, 2008| 02:53 am | Posted by vlk

It is somewhat surprising that astronomers haven’t cottoned on to Lowess curves yet. That’s probably a good thing because I think people already indulge in smoothing far too much for their own good, and Lowess makes for a very powerful hammer. But the fact that it is semi-parametric and is based on polynomial least-squares fitting does make it rather attractive.

And, of course, sometimes it is unavoidable, or so I told Brad W. When one has too many points for a regular polynomial fit, and they are too scattered for a spline, and too few to try a wavelet “denoising”, and no real theoretical expectation of any particular model function, and all one wants is “a smooth curve, damnit”, then Lowess is just the ticket.

Well, almost.

There is one major problem — *how does one figure what the error bounds are on the “best-fit” Lowess curve?* Clearly, each fit at each point can produce an estimate of the error, but simply collecting the separate errors is not the right thing to do because they would all be correlated. I know how to propagate Gaussian errors in boxcar smoothing a histogram, but this is a whole new level of complexity. Does anyone know if there is software that can calculate reliable error bands on the smooth curve? We will take any kind of error model — Gaussian, Poisson, even the (local) variances in the data themselves.

Tags:

Brad Wargelin,

error bands,

error bars,

Fitting,

least-squares,

Loess,

Lowess,

polynomial,

question for statisticians,

smoothing Category:

Algorithms,

Fitting,

Methods,

Stat,

Uncertainty |

11 Comments