Dec 3rd, 2008| 12:31 am | Posted by hlee

Almost two year long scrutinizing some publications by astronomers gave me enough impression that astronomers live in the Gaussian world. You are likely to object this statement by saying that astronomers know and use Poisson, binomial, Pareto (power laws), Weibull, exponential, Laplace (Cauchy), Gamma, and some other distributions.^{[1]} This is true. I witness that these distributions are referred in many publications; however, when it comes to obtaining “BEST FIT estimates for the parameters of interest” and “their ERROR (BARS)”, suddenly everything goes back to the Gaussian world.^{[2]}

Borel Cantelli Lemma (from Planet Math): because of mathematical symbols, a link was made but any probability books have the lemma with proofs and descriptions.

Continue reading ‘Borel Cantelli Lemma for the Gaussian World’ »

Tags:

Borel Cantelli Lemma,

CLT,

families of distributions,

gaussian,

grand challenge,

measure,

non-Gaussian,

probability,

statisticians Category:

arXiv,

Astro,

Bad AstroStat,

Cross-Cultural,

Frequentist,

Jargon,

News,

Quotes,

Stat,

Uncertainty |

Comment
Sep 10th, 2008| 10:15 am | Posted by hlee

Physicists believe that the Gaussian law has been proved in mathematics while mathematicians think that it was experimentally established in physics — **Henri Poincare**

Continue reading ‘Why Gaussianity?’ »

Tags:

CLT,

Gaussianity,

Henry Poincare,

IEEE,

normal,

signal processing,

signal processing magazine,

Why Category:

arXiv,

Cross-Cultural,

Data Processing,

Fitting,

Frequentist,

Methods,

Physics,

Quotes,

Stat,

Uncertainty |

Comment
Jun 26th, 2008| 08:03 pm | Posted by hlee

What if R. A. Fisher was hired by the Royal Observatory in spite that his interest was biology and agriculture, or W. S. Gosset^{[1]} instead of brewery? An article by E.L. Lehmann made me think this *what if*. If so, astronomers could have handled errors better than now. Continue reading ‘On the history and use of some standard statistical models’ »

Jan 25th, 2008| 12:53 pm | Posted by hlee

I have been observing some sorts of misconception about statistics and statistical nomenclature evolution in astronomy, which I believe, are attributed to the lack of references in the astronomical society. There are some textbooks designed for junior/senior science and engineering students, which are likely unknown to astronomers. Example-wise, these books are not suitable, to my knowledge. Although I never expect astronomers to learn standard graduate (mathematical) statistics textbooks, I do wish astronomers go beyond Numerical Recipes (W. H. Press, S. A. Teukolsky, W. T. Vetterling, & B. P. Flannery) and Error Data Reduction and Analysis for the Physical Sciences (P. R. Bevington & D. K. Robinson). Here are some good ones written by astronomers, engineers, and statisticians: Continue reading ‘Books – a boring title’ »

Tags:

application,

Bayesian,

book,

books,

box plot,

cartoon,

chi-square,

CLT,

correlation,

delta method,

EDA,

error bars,

Frequentist,

gaussian,

references,

scatter plot Category:

Cross-Cultural,

Data Processing,

Misc,

Stat |

12 Comments
Jan 18th, 2008| 02:24 pm | Posted by hlee

Seven preprints were chosen this week and two mentioned model selection. Continue reading ‘[ArXiv] 3rd week, Jan. 2008’ »

Tags:

AIC,

Bayesian,

BIC,

CLT,

correlation,

F-test,

FoF,

hypothesis testing,

Kolmogorov-Smirnoff test,

LRT,

Model Selection,

modeling,

sunspots Category:

arXiv |

Comment
Dec 31st, 2007| 02:06 pm | Posted by hlee

This will be the last [ArXiv] of this year (for some of you, the previous year). Continue reading ‘The last [ArXiv] of 2007’ »